05

Authority research

Link-gap research

in-house · Aug–Sep 2026

From competitor references to 50 verified opportunities worth pursuing.

Role /
Competitor mapping, scoring model and shortlist
Period /
Aug–Sep 2026
Context /
In-house, two brands
Scope /
Link-gap research

Decisive choice / Relevance before authority

  • 56competitors confirmed, from 62 reviewedMy research
  • 205referring domains shared by competitors240 validated backlink records
  • 50verified opportunities, from 218 candidates reviewedWeighted scoring model
  • 15%weight given to authority; relevance came firstScoring model

Research question /

Which sources reference our competitors, which of them are relevant to us, and what would we need to publish to deserve the same reference?

Research inventory /

Different units · these records are not stages of one funnel
Competitor set
62reviewed56confirmed
Backlink evidence
240page-level records validated
Shared references
205referring domains shared by competitors

Competitor set /

56 confirmed62 reviewed

Where competitors' references came from: universities · business schools · Erasmus+ organisations · directories · job portals · media

I can't reconcile these populations with the evaluated opportunities, so the counts are not sequential steps.

Qualification and prioritisation /

Authority was 15% of the decision. A strong but irrelevant source was rejected.

218 opportunities reviewed against a weighted scoring model. Every rejected source was logged with its reason.

I'm not publishing the remaining weights, thresholds or individual accepted and rejected records. Competitor, institution and contact names stay withheld.

Lost links identified to recover
30
Domains identified to protect
4
Linkable assets proposed
12

These are separate research findings, not completed recovery, protection or asset-production outcomes.

Decision /

Situation
The competitor gap list was full of high-authority education sites, and ranking by authority score alone would have put them first.
Options
Rank by authority score, or ask first whether the site had a reason to link to us.
Decision
I weighted sector relevance above authority, and logged every source I rejected with the reason.
Why
A link from a site with no reason to mention us would be hard to earn and would not resemble the links competitors hold.
What I observed
Large education domains with high authority scores failed the relevance gate and went into the rejected log; borderline ones were kept for manual review. No outreach has been sent, so this research has no link or traffic result.

Research deliverable /

218opportunities reviewed

50verified opportunities

Opportunities /

50 verified218 reviewed

Both counts are opportunities: 50 verified from 218 reviewed. The competitor set above is a separate population, not an earlier stage of this one.

Across 16 institutions, ranked by priority, each with the asset it needs.

EVIDENCE TRAIL

  1. Diagnosed — Done
  2. Prioritised — Done
  3. Outreach — Not started

The research ended at a verified shortlist in September 2026. Outreach and asset production were the next phase and had not started when I left.

My Aug–Sep 2026 link-gap research workbook: Semrush data and manual source validation (private).

What this shows /

I ask why someone would link before I ask them to, and I log what I reject as carefully as what I keep. The limit is real: the research ended at a verified shortlist, and outreach had not started when I left.